Published on: 03/21/2024, updated on: 03/21/2024

4Health vs. Taste of the Wild: Which Should YOU Choose?

This post contains affiliate links, and we may be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on our links, at no additional cost to you.

Hey there, fellow dog lovers! Gail here, proud mama of two adorable pups, Max and Luna. As a lifelong canine enthusiast, I know that finding the perfect food for your furry friend can be a daunting task.

That's why I've put my passion for research (and my love of taste-testing with my own dogs) to work, comparing two of the most popular natural dog food brands: 4Health and Taste of the Wild.

In this ultimate showdown, we'll dive deep into the ingredient quality, nutrient profiles, and overall value of each brand to help you determine which one is the best fit for your dog's unique needs. So, grab a cup of coffee (or a dog treat), and let's get started!

Why Choose Natural Dog Food?


Dog food dry kibble in a stainless steel dog food bowl

Before we jump into the brand battle, let's take a moment to discuss why you might opt for a natural dog food in the first place. High-quality natural formulas can offer a wide range of benefits for your pup, including:

  • Shinier, healthier coat
  • Increased energy levels
  • Improved digestion
  • Fewer allergy symptoms

Of course, every dog is different, so it's crucial to find a natural food that caters to your furry friend's specific requirements.

Meet the Contenders

In the blue corner, we have 4Health, a brand exclusive to Tractor Supply Company known for providing premium, natural formulas at budget-friendly prices. Their key features include:

  • Real meat as the first ingredient
  • No corn, wheat, or soy fillers
  • Added probiotics for digestive health
  • Omega fatty acids for skin and coat health

And in the red corner, we have Taste of the Wild, a popular natural dog food brand that takes inspiration from the ancestral diet of wild canines. They're known for:

  • Novel protein sources like bison, venison, and smoked salmon
  • Grain-free formulas
  • Probiotics for digestive support
  • Antioxidant-rich fruits and vegetables
Related  Purina Beyond Dog Food Review | Ranch Raised Lamb & White Meat Chicken

Let the showdown begin!

Round 1: 4Health Original Salmon & Potato vs. Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream

4health Salmon Potato Formula Adult Dog Food

Tale of the Tape:

4Health Original Salmon & PotatoTaste of the Wild Pacific Stream
AAFCO RatingExceeds GuidelinesExceeds Guidelines
Ingredient QualityHighHigh
Best ForAdult Dogs, Sensitive StomachsAdult Dogs, Sensitive Stomachs

Nutrient Breakdown:

4Health Original Salmon & PotatoTaste of the Wild Pacific Stream
Protein25%25%
Fat14%15%
Fiber3%3%
Omega-6 Fatty Acids2.5%2.4%
Omega-3 Fatty Acids0.5%0.3%

Ingredient Spotlight:

  • Both formulas feature real salmon as the first ingredient, providing high-quality protein and omega-3 fatty acids.
  • 4Health includes potatoes, while Taste of the Wild uses sweet potatoes. Both offer complex carbs for sustained energy, but some dogs may have sensitivities to potatoes.

Bioavailability Breakdown:

Bioavailability refers to how easily your dog's body can absorb and use the nutrients in their food. In this case, both foods offer highly digestible ingredients, but 4Health's slightly higher omega-3 content may give it a minor edge in terms of bioavailability.

The Verdict:

In this close match-up, 4Health comes out slightly ahead due to its higher omega-3 content and more affordable price point. However, both formulas offer excellent nutrition for adult dogs with sensitive stomachs.

Round 2: 4Health Grain-Free Beef & Potato vs. Taste of the Wild High Prairie

taste

Tale of the Tape:

4Health Grain-Free Beef & PotatoTaste of the Wild High Prairie
AAFCO RatingExceeds GuidelinesExceeds Guidelines
Ingredient QualityHighHigh
Best ForAdult Dogs, Grain SensitivitiesActive Dogs, Novel Protein

Nutrient Breakdown:

4Health Grain-Free Beef & PotatoTaste of the Wild High Prairie
Protein27%32%
Fat15%18%
Fiber3.5%4%
Omega-6 Fatty Acids2.4%2.8%
Omega-3 Fatty Acids0.4%0.3%

Ingredient Spotlight:

  • The 4Health formula features beef as the main protein source, while Taste of the Wild includes bison and venison. These novel proteins are ideal for dogs with sensitivities to common allergens like chicken or beef.
  • Both foods are grain-free, catering to dogs with grain allergies or sensitivities.

Bioavailability Breakdown:

Both formulas offer highly bioavailable protein sources, but Taste of the Wild's higher protein and fat content may be more beneficial for active dogs who need more energy-dense nutrition.

Related  Best Dog Food for Shih Tzus: Options for Sensitive Stomachs and Allergies

Taste of the Wild also includes a variety of antioxidant-rich fruits and vegetables, which can help support immune function and overall health.

The Verdict:

For active dogs or those who thrive on novel protein sources, Taste of the Wild's High Prairie formula is the winner. However, 4Health's Grain-Free Beef & Potato is still an excellent choice for most adult dogs, particularly those with grain sensitivities, and comes at a more budget-friendly price point.

Within the Brand Comparisons

4Health Brand

4Health Brand

If you're looking for a more affordable option within the 4Health line, consider their Original Chicken & Rice formula. While it does contain grains, it offers a balanced nutrient profile at an even lower price point than their grain-free options.

Taste of the Wild Brand

aste of the Wild Brand

For dogs who prefer a fish-based formula, Taste of the Wild's Pacific Stream Puppy Recipe is a great choice. It features salmon, ocean fish meal, and sweet potatoes, providing optimal nutrition for growing pups.

Vet's Corner

I reached out to Dr. Sarah Johnson, a renowned veterinarian and animal nutritionist, to get her take on the importance of novel proteins and grain-free diets. Here's what she had to say:

"Novel proteins like bison, venison, and duck can be incredibly beneficial for dogs with food sensitivities or allergies. These less common protein sources are less likely to trigger an immune response, making them a great option for dogs who struggle with more traditional ingredients.

As for grain-free diets, they can be a good choice for some dogs, particularly those with grain allergies or sensitivities. However, it's essential to choose a grain-free formula that still provides balanced nutrition from other sources, such as potatoes, sweet potatoes, or legumes."

Max and Luna's Taste Test

Of course, no dog food comparison would be complete without input from the ultimate experts: the dogs themselves! I decided to put 4Health and Taste of the Wild to the test with my own furry taste-testers, Max and Luna.

First up was 4Health's Grain-Free Beef & Potato formula. Both dogs showed immediate interest, eagerly chomping away at their bowls. Max, my usually picky eater, seemed particularly enthused, licking his bowl clean in record time.

Related  Blue Buffalo vs. Wellness – Healthy Dog Food Review (2020)

Next, we tried Taste of the Wild's High Prairie formula. Once again, both dogs dove in with gusto, clearly enjoying the novel protein flavors. Luna, my active Border Collie, seemed to have a bit more pep in her step after finishing her meal, which I attribute to the higher protein and fat content.

Ask Gail

Do you have questions about 4Health, Taste of the Wild, or finding the perfect food for your pup? I'm here to help! Submit your questions using the form below, and I'll personally respond with my insights and recommendations.

The Final Verdict

After extensive research, taste-testing with Max and Luna, and insights from a veterinary expert, I've concluded that both 4Health and Taste of the Wild offer high-quality, natural nutrition for dogs. However, the best choice for your furry friend will depend on their unique needs and your budget.

For most dogs, 4Health offers exceptional value, providing high-quality ingredients and balanced nutrition at an affordable price point. Their grain-free options are particularly impressive, catering to dogs with grain sensitivities without breaking the bank.

On the other hand, Taste of the Wild's novel protein sources and higher fat and protein levels may be worth the extra cost for highly active dogs or those with severe allergies. Their commitment to using antioxidant-rich fruits and vegetables is also a significant plus.

Ultimately, the key to finding the perfect food for your dog is understanding their individual needs and consulting with your veterinarian. I hope this in-depth comparison, complete with expert insights and real-life taste tests, has provided you with the information and tools necessary to make an informed decision for your beloved furry friend!

Remember, if you have any questions or need personalized recommendations, just submit them using the "Ask Gail" form above. I'm always here to help you navigate the world of natural dog food and find the best options for your unique pup.

Until next time, keep those tails wagging and bowls filled with the good stuff!

Glossary of Key Terms

AAFCO: The Association of American Feed Control Officials, which sets the nutritional standards for pet food in the United States.

Bioavailability: The ease with which a dog's body can absorb and utilize the nutrients in their food.

Novel Protein: A protein source that is not commonly used in dog food, such as bison, venison, or duck. These proteins can be beneficial for dogs with allergies or sensitivities to more common ingredients like chicken or beef.

Grain-Free: A type of dog food that does not contain any grains, such as wheat, corn, or rice. Grain-free diets are often recommended for dogs with grain allergies or sensitivities.

Probiotics: Beneficial bacteria that help support digestive health and immune function.

Omega-3 and Omega-6 Fatty Acids: Essential fatty acids that play a crucial role in maintaining skin and coat health, as well as supporting overall well-being.

Related Posts
06/11/2019
Best Wet and Dry Dog Food for Yeast Infections: Preventing it and Enhancing Treatment

 Is your best buddy scratching excessively or tilting his heads to the side suddenly? Do you see red patches in his skin, drastic hair loss, and unbearable odors when giving him a good scratch? Have you been alarmed by a sudden liquid discharge from his ear? If you answered yes to any of these, then […]

06/13/2019
Best Dog Food for Pomeranians: Rich Nutrition for Fun-Sized Fur Balls

While Pomeranians may be a toy breed, they're known for being just as vigorous and spirited as any larger breed. That means their metabolism calls for a diet dense in calories and rich in nutrients. Even though there are products out there that boast of being suitable for all breeds and all life stages, there […]

02/12/2020
Best Dog Food for Your Goldendoodle — Sincere Love, Sincere Food

Goldenpoo, groodles, doodles, or whichever cute silly name you refer to your goldendoodle adds to the fact that their level of awesomeness is so irresistible. These charming designer dogs deserve nothing but good food to fill their bellies. As the saying “there is no more sincere love than the love of food” goes, and so […]

1 2 3 34
PetFashionWeek provides comprehensive resources for everything you need to know about your dog. We research and review the dog related products so you don’t have to. Let your furry friend be at their best with our professional tips. We may earn commission on eligible purchases you make using our links at no additional cost to you.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram